Debate debunks myths about foreigners
Brian Hayward WEEKEND POST REPORTER
WHILE foreigners boost the local economy by bringing in expertise, they need to be more willing to integrate with locals, according to community and business leaders quizzed this week during a live debate as part of the Friendly City Project.
Today the week-long project draws to a close, having established facts and debunked myths around the effects of immigration on Nelson Mandela Bay.
The highlight of the project was Wednesday‘s live debate, hosted by Weekend Post and The Herald.
The debate, which was broadcast live on the Friendly City Project Internet blog site, drew heated responses from both the panel and readers online.
The panel consisted of Dr Mamisa Chabula-Nxiweni, municipal head of the environment and health unit; Odwa Mtati, chief executive of the Port Elizabeth Regional Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Percci); George Irvine, director of the Institute for Spirituality; Dr Janet Cherry, a lecturer in development studies; and Nokhita Mona, head of the Uitenhage and Despatch Development Initiative (UDDI). It was convened by veteran journalist Paddi Clay.
Quizzed as to the reason why the Bay experienced fewer xenophobic clashes this year than the rest of the country, Mtati attributed it to foreigners living in isolated communities.
Reacting to the question, a blogger identified as “MC” said: “I am an ex-policeman with 17 years‘ experience/service. In my experience Zimbabweans and Somalians are not involved in criminal activities. Nigerians are the real problem. They are involved in drug running, prostitution and hijackings. If you don‘t believe me, ask any policeman, white or black!”
Fellow blogger Sipho Mosondo disagreed, saying: “I think it‘s a sweeping statement from MC to brand all Nigerians as criminals. There are a few good Nigerians who contribute positively to Mandela Bay.”
As the heat was turned up on the panel, Mona called for a three-tiered system, including for foreigners to better integrate themselves with locals, for the community to respect foreigners‘ rights and for government to institute more effective policies to look after immigrants.
Irvine bemoaned the lack of community leadership dealing with issues arising between immigrants and the community.
Chabula-Nxiweni said there were many unused spaces in the city which could be used to create immigrant-processing and integration facilities.
With bloggers joining in the debate globally, comments continued to pour in long after the debate had ended. Today, it continues. You can log on and have you say.